Supreme Court Supports Parents' Right to Opt Out of LGBTQ Books in Elementary Schools

The Supreme Court ruled in favor of parents objecting to LGBTQ-themed books approved for elementary school use. The 6-3 vote supported parents' claim of violating religious rights by not allowing opt-outs for their children. Justice Samuel Alito stated the decision burdened parents' free exercise of religion. The conservative majority supported the ruling, while liberal Justice Sonia Sotomayor dissented, warning of chaos in public schools.

The dispute began in 2022 when the Montgomery County Board of Education revised its curriculum to include more LGBTQ-themed storybooks. Approved books like 'Uncle Bobby’s Wedding' and 'Born Ready' aim to reflect the diverse community. Despite being available, teachers are not mandated to use them. Plaintiffs, including a Muslim couple and parent group Kids First, argued for the right to shield their children from conflicting content with their religious beliefs.

The Trump administration supported the challengers, but lower courts ruled in favor of the school board. The Supreme Court's history of backing religious rights in LGBTQ-related cases was highlighted, including a previous ruling favoring a Christian web designer who declined to work on same-sex weddings.